“For those of us who prefer entertaining or at least
enlightening science fiction films, than avoid The Divide like the radioactive
cloud that hangs over the doomed characters in this darkly depressing
film.”
Science Fiction, Post-apocalyptic, Drama
Staring - Lauren German/Eva, , Milo Ventimiglia/Josh,
Courtney B. Vance/Devlin, Ashton Holmes/Adrien, Rosanna Arquette/Marilyn, Iván
González/Sam, Michael Eklund/Bobby and
Abbey Thickson/Wendi
Director - Xavier Gens
Writer(s) - Karl Mueller and Eron Sheean
Rated R - Disturbing strong violence, sexuality, and
pervasive language
1 hr., 52 min.
I watch every genre film that comes out in any given
year, with very few exceptions. I probably skip horror films more than any of
my three favorite genres, because of my dislike for these sub-genres: slasher,
torture-porn and found-footage. Fantasy films seldom contain elements that I
find distasteful, so I seldom miss any of these films, except for the extremely
cheap ones or films aimed at young children. Science fiction is my favorite type of
film, so a film has to contain elements that I find very distasteful or just
plain dull for me to pass over. Even so, I occasionally go out of my comfort
zone and watch a science fiction film that I am fairly certain I will find
difficult to watch. Sometimes I am rewarded with a film that surprises me (like
Phase 7 did last year), but more often than not, I am sorry that I spent the
time and effort to watch a film I could not appreciate even on a purely
intellectual level (The Road – 2009 –immediately springs to mind). I have put
off watching The Divide for some time, but I finally bolstered my courage and
watched this post-apocalyptic drama.
The film opens with Eva and her boyfriend Sam looking out
their apartment window and seeing missiles streaking across the New York
skyline. When the first explosion hits, they immediately rush out of the
apartment and down the emergency stairwell. Most of the residents of the building
are already running down the stairs and there is much pushing and shoving as
people begin to panic. They finally get to the ground floor and the exit, when
another closer explosion rocks the building and forces them back into the
apartment building. Desperate for shelter, they see an open door leading to the basement
of the building, but a man is trying to close it. Eva, Sam and a few others
push against the door and manage to force their way in.
Once inside the basement, Mickey, who is the building
superintendent, tells the small group that he is in charge until it is safe to
leave. Marilyn’s young daughter Wendi begins to complain and keeps repeating
her need to go home. Mickey informs her and everyone that the radiation dust
from the fallout of the nuclear explosion will kill everyone, so no one can
leave until he says so. The rest of the group is made up of a yuppie gay man
Josh, his younger artist brother Adrien, Josh’s friend Bobby and an African-American
man Devlin, who no one seems to know. As the days pass into weeks, the group
grows increasingly aware that Mickey is hiding something and they suspect that
is the reason he will not allow them to enter his private room.
A loud banging is heard outside the steel door that
separates them from the contaminated air and Mickey grabs an axe to hold off
potential intruders. The invaders use a blow torch to cut the locked door and
enter. What happens next is a complete right-turn in the film’s plot and when
this portion of the film concludes, The Divide goes right back to where its
plot was headed originally.
The Divide is the type of Post-apocalyptic story that
shows humanity at its worst. As the film wears on and on, the characters in the
film all begin to gradually decline both mentally and physically. One reason
for the physical deterioration, which is only implied in the film, is that
because the door was breached, they are all gradually dying of radiation contamination.
Once this becomes obvious, not only do the characters begin to act more and
more selfish and sadistic, but as a viewer I lost interest in their survival because
I knew they were not going to do so. The only thing that could have made The
Divide a compelling drama for me was seeing these characters struggle for survival.
Once this hope was taken away, there was little to keep me interested; other
than the perverse voyeuristic pleasure in watching these characters deteriorate
to the point of near savagery. I do not find these type of scenes interesting,
so the film lost me before it was even halfway over.
One thing that stood out to me – and not in a good way –
was the soundtrack. There are many sequences in the film where the camera pans slowly
across all the characters in various stages of depression to show passage of
time and every single time this long repetitive piano music plays incessantly
over these shots. It was maddening to the point where I finally had to fast
forward through these merciless montages!
The only highlight of the film is Michael Biehn as Mickey,
who starts out being an unlikeable totalitarian bastard, but grows into a
stronger and more compassionate character, whose hidden motives are cleverly and
expertly revealed by Biehn’s subtle acting. The rest of the cast are written so
poorly that you have to feel sorry for the actors and actresses playing the
roles; particularly Rosanna Arquette who’s character suffers the worst
indignities in the film.
I honestly don’t understand how a film like The Divide
gets made. The three million dollar budget was spent I’m assuming on the mostly
talented cast. How anyone reading the screenplay would consider this worth
investing in is beyond me, as even if the story made sense – which because of
the previously mentioned “right turn” in the plot – it doesn’t, it portrays
such a negative view on humanity that only someone who has a similar pessimistic
viewpoint would find this story worth filming. If you are of a similar mental
bent, than by all means “enjoy” The Divide. For those of us who prefer entertaining
or at least enlightening science fiction films, than avoid The Divide like the
radioactive cloud that hangs over the doomed characters in this darkly depressing
film.
TECHNICAL: Acting – 8 Directing – 7 Cinematography – 7
Script – 5 Special Effects – 7
VISCERAL: Visual – 7 Auditory – 5 Intellectual – 6 Emotional
– 6 Involvement – 5
TOTAL - 63
Fritz, that sounds like a fascinating film. "Humanity at its worst." Hard to imagine.
ReplyDeleteMaurice,
ReplyDeleteSarcasm doesn’t always translate well in text, but I’m assuming by stating that you think The Divide “sounds like a fascinating film” that you don’t agree with my assessment of the film. If realism in a film means that everything and everyone in a film has to be gloomy, depressing and pessimistic, than I guess I don’t like “realistic” films. I don’t need all my science fiction films to be unnaturally cheerful, uplifting and optimistic, but if a film is going to show a harsh reality that challenges the human spirit, than I prefer to have at least a few of the characters in the film accept the challenge and not just lay down and die; or worst, make the situation even worse by torturing or killing the other characters. This is what happens in The Divide and I don’t find these human degradations either entertaining or interesting. Perhaps someone who thinks that these types of films are a good warning or representation of the current state of human affaires would like this film, but I just find them too damned depressing.
If you do watch The Divide and find some merit in it, I’d be happy to read your reasoning behind that opinion. I’ll most likely still disagree with it, but it may open my mind and help me look at this type of film in a different way.
Thanks for the comments, Maurice!
Josh wasn't a 'yuppie gay man' I seem to recall stuff with Marilyn and (nearly) Eva that would say he was straight. And definitely not a yuppie, he was kind of a scumbag.
ReplyDeleteNot being nitpicky here btw just seems a pretty big mistake is all.
Hi, J.J!
ReplyDeleteI'm a little hesitant to contradict your corrections of my assessment of Joss's character, because it has been long enough since I watched The Divide that I don't remember the specific traits of any of the characters in the film. To keep my reviews short, I tend to paint the characters personalities with very quick strokes; particularly a film I disliked as much as this one. If you say Joss was a straight "scumbag", I'll take your word for it. However, that same adjective could be used to describe most of the characters in The Divide by the end of the movie.
I'm glad you took the time and effort to comment on my review of The Divide, J.J., but it may be more interesting to give me your opinion of the film itself. If you disagreed with my negative assessment of The Divide, then tell me why. I don't mind constructive criticism, but I much prefer an exchange of ideas and opinions.
Hi Fritz,
ReplyDeleteWell I can assure you he was.
Like I said I wasn't being nitpicky and I am sorry if I came off as a douchebag in my comment. I'm kind of abrupt in speech....it can read wrong.
Definitely agree that everyone was a scumbag by the end (don't know whether to excuse Josh and Bobby from extra hate as they were suffering more radiation poisoning than the others?)
I did like this movie rather a lot though,
Realistic? Not at all.....
But that's never hindered my enjoyment of a movie before :)
Other than a very bleak worldview what did you dislike so much?
I know many people felt short changed by the lack of explanation with the 'white suit guys' and precisely what the reason was for the 'war' and furthermore, if it was the world or just New York under attack.
I'll check back quicker this time, lol
Welcome back, J. J.!
ReplyDeleteI didn’t take offence at your correction of my assessment of Joss’s character and since you are obviously much more of a fan of the film, I’m more than willing to assume your understanding of the characters in The Divide are better than mine. The only way I would even attempt to disagree with you on this point would be for me to watch the film again and that is something I have no desire to do.
I think you are being overly generous to Joss and Bobby by crediting their increase exposure to radiation for their devolving antisocial behavior. All the characters showed signs of radiation poisoning by the films end and yet some of them still demonstrated a modicum of civilized behavior. The most compassionate character – and the POV character throughout the film – was Eva and she ultimately was the only one who continually attempted to maintain a positive attitude.
It was not a lack of realism that kept me from enjoying The Divide. Nor was it a lack of an explanation of who the men in the white suits were. Nor was it the lack of a larger explanation of what caused the nuclear attack on New York or whether the scale of the attack was nation or worldwide. It most definitely was the, as you put it “the bleak world view”, that kept me from enjoying or even finding an appreciative understanding of the film. Watching characters devolve into depraved, immoral and selfish people is not my idea of fun or entertainment. If the film had given me the impression of having a greater meaning or some sort of overall moral message, I might have at least come away from watching it with a begrudging admiration for it; but it did not do this and only seemed to relish wallowing in the character’s misery, self-pity and depression. Once again, this is not my idea of fun.
What ultimately made me dislike the film most of all was the ending. Eva finally escapes the basement into the devastation of a demolished New York City. It is clear from her reaction to the environment and where the director chose to end the film that Eva will not survive for long and it compounds the feeling of hopelessness that the film had already beaten into the viewers for most of The Divide’s running time. I don’t require a film to have a positive or upbeat ending to enjoy it (The Cabin in the Woods was one of my favorite films of 2012 and everyone dies in that one), but when a film’s major point seems to be to show just how worthless humans are and how capable they are of being inhumane to one another, I for one would rather not watch it.
Thanks for the feedback and interesting discourse, J. J.!